top of page

The Environmental Advantages of Black Soldier Fly vs Anaerobic Digestion

Executive Summary:

This comprehensive report dissects the advantages of Black Soldier Fly (BSF) farming compared to Anaerobic Digestion (AD). Grounded in a detailed analysis, this report shows how BSF outperforms AD in carbon sequestration efficiency but also offers a dual benefit of waste conversion and protein production, making it an unparalleled choice for sustainable organic waste management.


As the world grapples with the imperative to adopt sustainable waste management practices, the comparative analysis between BSF farming and AD provides invaluable insights into the environmental efficiency and multifaceted benefits of these technologies. This report delves into the nuanced advantages that BSF farming brings to the forefront, surpassing the capabilities of traditional AD processes.

1. Carbon Sequestration Efficiency:

Detailed Analysis: The carbon mass balance analysis reveals that BSF farming surpasses Anaerobic Digestion (AD) in retaining carbon during the conversion of feed. While AD experiences a notable 48.62% carbon loss to the atmosphere, BSF demonstrates remarkable efficiency by limiting the loss to just 28.54%. This outcome emphasises the ability of BSF to prevent carbon release during waste conversion, showcasing its superior carbon sequestration capabilities.

2. Climate Impact Reduction:

Utilizing Research-Derived Formula: Leveraging a research-derived formula, the report demonstrates that BSF leads in carbon sequestration efficiency. For every 1000 metric tons of feed processed, BSF achieves an impressive sequestration of 62.6 tonnes of CO2 when compared to AD. This significant figure underscores the pivotal role of BSF in actively mitigating climate impact by removing carbon from the atmosphere during the waste conversion process. This data emphasises the substantial environmental benefits that BSF brings, far surpassing the capabilities of AD.

3. Resource Utilization and Circular Economy:

Dual Functionality: Beyond carbon sequestration, BSF goes a step further by converting organic waste into a valuable protein source. This dual functionality aligns seamlessly with the principles of a circular economy, where waste is transformed into a resource. In contrast, AD primarily concentrates on energy production through biogas, and its byproducts may not possess the same versatility and value as the protein-rich output from BSF. This highlights BSF's capacity to create a closed-loop system that maximises resource utilisation.

4. Energy vs. Protein Production:

Protein-Rich Output: While AD focuses on generating biogas for energy purposes, the unique advantage of BSF lies in the protein-rich output it produces. The protein derived from BSF is not only sustainable but also serves as a nutrient-dense alternative to traditional protein sources. This dual-purpose approach highlights the versatility of BSF in addressing both waste management and protein needs simultaneously, making it a more efficient and multifaceted solution compared to AD.

5. Space Optimization and Scalability:

Adaptability to Diverse Settings: BSF systems require less space than AD facilities, providing enhanced adaptability to diverse settings, particularly in urban environments where space constraints are common. The compact nature of BSF systems enhances their scalability, allowing for efficient waste conversion in various locations. This scalability further sets them apart from the space-intensive nature of AD, making BSF a practical and efficient choice for waste conversion on a broader scale.

In conclusion, for certain feed's BSF farming emerges as an environmental frontrunner over AD. Its carbon sequestration efficiency, dual-purpose waste conversion, and protein production, resource utilisation, and scalability, position BSF as a superior choice for sustainable organic waste management. This report underscores the pivotal role of BSF can have by working in tandem with AD in shaping the future environmentally conscious waste processing solutions. Further research should be conducted into the practical application of redirecting poor performing AD input's to BSF farming.

We have bespoke packages for the AD and feed recycling industry showing how we can monetise your products while making the industry more sustainable. Please contact us for details and to set up an appraisal:



bottom of page